Cranmer: Conservatives launch Debt Clock

Via Cranmer: Conservatives launch Debt Clock:

What you could buy with the interest on Labour’s debt:

If Britain was not going to spend £63.7 billion a year on debt interest, we could:

Abolish fuel duty, inheritance tax, and stamp duty or

Abolish council tax or

Pay for 1.5 million extra police officers or

Pay for 1.6 million extra teachers or

Pay for 1.9 million extra nurses or

Cut the basic rate of income tax by over 13p.

Britain will spend more next year on paying the interest on Labour’s debt than on educating our schoolchildren. The Dedicated Schools Grant in 2010-11 will be £31.9 billion. Debt interest payments will be £42.9 billion in 2010-11, and are estimated to rise to £63.7 billion by 2013-4.

And so on…

How to avoid future encounters with financial meltdown » The Cobden Centre

Cobden CentreMy Cobden Centre colleague and Chief Executive of Tyler Capital, James Tyler, explains how we came close to financial collapse and what to do about it:

Fractional Reserve Banking (FRB) is an inherently unstable complex system.

Each and every bubble and crisis has some kind of link to FRB, going back thousands of years.

Even where financial crises are caused by natural disasters (the San Francisco earthquake of 1906 being a prime example), the financial crisis only followed because banks did not have enough reserves to pay out worried depositors – due to fractional reserves.

In a nutshell, depositors wanted what they thought was their property back, only to find it did not exist.

Over 70% of people in the UK believe that money placed in an instant access account remains their property.  This is not the case.

Read more: How to avoid future encounters with financial meltdown » The Cobden Centre.

Irving Fisher, “100% Money”

Via The Cobden Centre » Honest money, a summary of economist Irving Fisher’s “100% Money”:

The 100% proposal is the opposite of radical. What it asks, in principle, is a return from the present extraordinary and ruinous system of lending the same money 8 or 10 times over, to the conservative safety-deposit system of the old goldsmiths, before they began lending out improperly what was entrusted to them for safekeeping. It was this abuse of trust which, after being accepted as standard practice, evolved into modern deposit banking.

FTSE 100: stock market has best month in more than six years – Telegraph

Via FTSE 100: stock market has best month in more than six years – Telegraph:

The stock market has enjoyed its best month in more than six years, boosting the savings of millions of investors and bringing hope that the worst of the recession may be over.

The FTSE 100 index of leading shares climbed 8.5 per cent in July, adding £134 billion to the value of the stock market, its best monthly performance since the fall of Baghdad during the second Gulf war in April, 2003.

The rise in share prices followed a series of strong profit figures from Britain’s biggest companies, with many proving to investors that they are coping well in the recession by cutting costs.

However, according to Austrian-School Theorists1:

[U]ninterrupted stock market growth never indicates favorable economic conditions. Quite the contrary: all such growth provides the most unmistakable sign of credit expansion unbacked by real savings, expansion which feeds an artificial boom that will invariably culminate in a severe stock market crisis.

In other words, and most unfortunately, the present stock market conditions are an illusion produced by quantitative easing that will not last. And:

The crash will take place as soon as economic agents begin to doubt the continuance of the expansionary process, observe a slowdown or halt in credit expansion and in short, become convinced that a crisis and recession will appear in the near future. At that point the fate of the stock market is sealed.

  1. De Soto, “Money Bank Credit and Economic Cycles”, p462 []

Norwich North, the Greens and the credit crisis

Today while telling in Norwich North, I was joined by a charming lady from the Green Party.

In conversation, she indicated the Green view that the present crisis was caused by the liberalisation of banking and the operation of the free market. I explained the ways in which I disagreed.

These are the posts I recommended:

As I said earlier, perhaps the greatest of my dissatisfactions with the Green Party is their lack of a coherent explanation for misallocation (that is, waste) of resources, resource over-consumption and the boom-bust cycle. If we truly care about the environment and people’s well-being in it, good intentions and passion are not enough: we must understand the way society works and the factors affecting consumption.

In the meantime, all the best today, on polling day, to Chloe Smith.

FT.com – Nomura has Lehman’s old crown in sight

Via FT.com / Companies / Financial Services – Nomura has Lehman’s old crown in sight:

Ten months ago when Lehman Brothers collapsed, it would have been a stretch to suggest that the former investment bank might reclaim its crown as the biggest broker on the London Stock Exchange.

But on Monday the new owner of its European equities trading business, Nomura of Japan, said its newly constituted European equities arm was now the LSE’s third-largest broker, behind Credit Suisse and top-ranked Merrill Lynch.

British banks highly vulnerable to future shocks, Bank of England warns – Telegraph

Via British banks highly vulnerable to future shocks, Bank of England warns – Telegraph:

Britain’s banks remain over-indebted, highly vulnerable and harbour growing funding gaps which leave them susceptible to future shocks, the Bank of England has said.

In a sign of the strain facing nations’ public finances – including the UK’s – the report also revealed that the threat of a sovereign debt default has become one of the biggest concerns for investors. A survey put together for the report identified sovereign risk as a financial stability concern for the first time.

The report also laid out a number of key criteria banks will have to fulfil in the future – reforms which could transform the structure of the financial system. Among its recommendations were that in future banks should “face a credible threat of closure or wind down”, should have a “risk-based, pre-funded deposit insurance system”, should increase their levels of capital and liquidity, depending on their size, and should provide a “will” which explains how to dismantle them in the event of insolvency.

The Bank of England’s Financial Stability Report is available here. The summary is quite accessible.

However, to answer the underlying “why?” one must look elsewhere. It may also be worth considering this speech by the Earl of Caithness:

The Banking Bill which we are currently discussing in the House is very complex and detailed, but it does nothing to resolve the current banking crisis, which lies at the heart of our economic problems. … the fault that really needs correcting is our whole banking system.

The debate which must be reopened and made contemporary is that between the Banking and Currency Schools of the nineteenth century. At the time of the 1844 Bank Charter Act, the Currency School committed three errors which haunt us today. More to follow at The Cobden Centre.

Mervyn King warns that spending cuts and tax rises are needed – Telegraph

Speaking to the Treasury Committee of MPs, Mr King dealt a serious blow to Mr Brown’s political strategy of casting the next election as a choice between “Tory cuts” and “Labour investment.”

In the Budget in April, Alistair Darling set out plans to borrow an extra £700 billion over five years, taking the national debt to £1.3 trillion.

Simply paying the interest on that borrowing will soon cost more money than the Government spends on schools or defence.

via Mervyn King warns that spending cuts and tax rises are needed – Telegraph.

Gordon Brown surrenders key powers over financial regulation to Brussels – Telegraph

The European Commission and other EU officials are celebrating after the Prime Minister accepted on Thursday night the creation of European supervisors over national regulators.

Senior EU officials described how in return for a promise that Brussels regulators can not have power to tell the British government when, and by how much, to bail out banks, Mr Brown has given ground on a broad range of other supervisory powers.

via Gordon Brown surrenders key powers over financial regulation to Brussels – Telegraph.

See also King seeks empire and EU ‘risks lagging US on regulation’.

George Osborne: A New British Economic Model

A good speech from George Osborne:

We should not be satisfied with turning back the clock to how things were before the crisis, or we risk simply pumping the bubble back up.

That would mean failing to understand a crucial insight that has become increasingly clear – that the model of economic growth pursued over the last ten years is fundamentally broken.

We can no longer rely on cheap borrowing from China and the rest of Asia to fund our standard of living.

The drivers of change we have depended on – housing, banking and rising Government consumption – cannot be relied upon to drive growth in the decades ahead.

In short, you cannot build lasting prosperity on a mountain of debt.

via The Conservative Party | News | Speeches | George Osborne: A New British Economic Model .

UK ‘needs emergency Budget’ – Telegraph

The Policy Exchange has advised the next government that it must be prepared to make radical and immediate cuts to spending plans or face a serious risk of a full-scale sovereign debt crisis. In a new paper, it has also shown that only a third of the impending surge in government spending can be traced back to measures intended to combat the recession, with the rest going on increased budgets for ballooning government departments.

via UK ‘needs emergency Budget’ – Telegraph. The Policy Exchange report is here:

Government spending is growing far more quickly than in other countries, and faster than in previous recessions, think tank Policy Exchange today warns. A new report finds that the surge in spending is not being driven by the recession.

At most, 6% of the increased spending is going on public works, and just over a third is due to the rising cost of social security or debt. Instead of “investment”, most of the increase is due to a decision to spend more on consumption.

“A decision to spend more on consumption” — that is, borrowing to fund present expenditure: plainly unsustainable.

Yet more new money

Present economic circumstances seem perilously close to those described by scholars of the monetary theory of the trade cycle:

The Bank of England has pledged to pump another £50bn into the economy as it steps up efforts to haul the UK from its worst recession in at least two decades.

via Bank of England to pump another £50bn into economy as it steps up recession fight – Telegraph.

China has given its clearest warning to date that emergency monetary stimulus by Western governments risks setting off worldwide inflation and undermining global bond markets.

via China fears bond crisis as it slams quantitative easing – Telegraph.

Unfortunately:

Continuously injecting additional amounts of money where it creates temporary demand, together with an expectation of continuously rising prices, draws labour and resources into use in areas which will last only as long as the supply of new money.

Read more posts on economics.

US banks thought to need $55bn in capital – Telegraph

Bank of America, Citigroup and Wells Fargo will have to collectively find $55bn in fresh ordinary capital as a result of the US Treasury’s financial stress tests, details of which are due to be announced today.

The three banks – three of America’s four largest by assets – are expected to be among the institutions requiring the most capital following the publication of the long-awaited tests, designed to ascertain whether banks’ reserves are strong enough to survive further economic shock waves.

via US banks thought to need $55bn in capital – Telegraph.

Lloyds bad debts to soar 50% on HBOS loans – Times Online

Lloyds Banking Group, which is 44 per cent owned by the UK taxpayer, today warned that soaring bad debt from legacy HBOS customers will contribute to a 50 per cent rise in loan book write-offs in 2009 compared to last year.

Mr Daniels pointed out that its bad debts would be largely taken on by the taxpayer after Lloyds last month outlined an agreement to join the Government Asset Protection Scheme.

Under the scheme, Lloyds will transfer £260 billion worth of its most high risk loans to the Government. Lloyds will bear the first losses on loans up to £25 billion, with any further writedowns being taken by the taxpayer.

via Lloyds bad debts to soar 50% on HBOS loans – Times Online .

FT.com – Longer life raises bill for taxpayers

The projected value of the state pension collapses in the face of the rising cost of public sector pensions:

Billions of pounds have been added to the cost of unfunded public sector pensions as the various schemes from the NHS to civil servants, the armed forces and teachers have updated their assumptions about how long people will live, Watson Wyatt, the pensions consultants, said.

The NHS has become the latest to do so, with the government now expecting the typical employee to draw their pension for more than 30 years – to beyond their 90th birthday.

via FT.com / UK / Politics & policy – Longer life raises bill for taxpayers.

“The Pretence of Knowledge”: how economists come to make astrologers look good

It seems everyone is talking about swine flu and the financial crisis, but they seem to be most persistently interested in what has gone wrong with the economy. After I explained the key points of this Nobel Prize Lecture by F A Hayek to my hairdresser this morning, she had confirmed in her mind what she always knew: that economists cannot discover all they need to make accurate predictions.

This is something we all need to understand.

What follows is a precis of that 1974 lecture (sometimes quoted verbatim). It explains why and how the economic policies of the time contributed to inflation and unemployment and it points the way out of our present and coming difficulties.

This is its message:

  • Physical scientists can observe and measure the things that drive the sytems they are studying.
  • Society, and therefore the economy, is not like a physical system: many of the most important factors cannot be seen or measured. Consider the thoughts and intended actions of millions of people at different times, for example.
  • Economists and other social scientists, in their attempt to be scientific, ignore what they cannot measure.
  • Therefore, many of the most important factors affecting the economy are not considered, while some of those factors which can be measured are deliberately controlled.
  • The results are incorrect predictions and actions which positively harm society.

In a sentence: society is not a machine to be controlled, but a garden to be cultivated.

By the way, the remark about making astrologers look good is attributable to the Keynesian economist J K Galbraith:

The only function of economic forecasting is to make astrology look respectable.

The precis:

A Precis of “The Pretence of Knowledge”

The topic of this lecture is the chief practical problem of economists, who must now explain how to stop the accelerating inflation they have caused. In imitating the techniques of the physical sciences, economists have made grave errors of economic policy.

The assertion guided policy that there exists a positive correlation between total employment and the aggregate demand for goods and services. It implies we can permanently ensure full employment by maintaining total expenditure. This is fundamentally false and very harmful.
Read more

Quantitative easing explained: “Who would be a central banker at the moment?”

Quantitative Easing explainedFrom the FT, Quantitative Easing Explained provides an approachable description of the process.

However, Dr Anthony Evans writes:

Despite the confusing terminology, quantitative easing is nothing new. It is simply an exotic label for a discredited policy.

And:

The amount of currency in circulation was growing at 12% in January 2009, has consistently been expanding at a faster rate than GDP, and the Bank of England is responsible for this monetary expansion. What’s more, the consensus view of economic commentators is that a root cause of the financial crisis was artificially low interest rates and the resulting mis-allocations of capital. In short, the Bank’s solution is a larger dose of what caused the original disease.

Read his article for more.

Cameron – the age of austerity

Text here.

Satire from John Redwood MP » The Finance Director of UK PLC sends out the annual figures

I am delighted to report our most successful year ever. We made more progress to achieving our twin goals of increasing our losses and building up our levels of debt than ever before. Indeed, I am especially proud to be able to announce that in just two years we will be able to borrow more than all the previous managements of UK PLC and its predecessor companies over 1000 years. I think you will agree with me that this is a magnificent result.

Read more at John Redwood MP » The Finance Director of UK PLC sends out the annual figures.

From borrow and spend to an economy that saves and invests

George Osborne reacts to today’s budget: